We have now run 1,420+ strategy tests on 1,186 YouTube trading channels on decades of real prices. Only 20 channels earned our highest verdict, Proof — profitable in every nearby rule version, over many years.
Here is the strange part: 18 of the 20 winners teach the same underlying trade, just dressed in different indicators.
Win rates shown are from our own tests on SPY (1993–2026) and QQQ (1999–2026), not the videos' claims (Trading with FYERS: Bank Nifty / Nifty 2015–2026).
No channel matches that. Search every channel we tested →
Both passed every one of our checks, so they earned Proof like the others. But they are not the buy-the-dip trade this page is about. We mark them so nobody counts them as "one more dip-buy": the headline is 18 of 20, not 20 of 20.
So if US indexes stop bouncing, these two are the only Proof winners that would not fail on the same day. That is the whole reason for the tag.
↑ back to the tableThe 57-second version (made when the count was 14 of 740).
US stock indexes have spent three decades drifting up with short panics along the way. A forced seller today is usually gone by Thursday. So any rule that says "uptrend + short panic = buy" has been paid, whatever indicator it uses to spot the panic. That is also why the same rules mostly fail on gold, Bitcoin and forex in our tests — those markets don't owe anyone a bounce.
Not everything that works is a dip-buy. These strategies use other ideas and made money over many years, still profitable after doubling our trading costs. They earned Weak edge, not Proof: the profit is real but smaller, depends on the market, or not every nearby version passed.
The pattern here: trend-following and opening-breakout ideas, mostly on Indian indexes, gold and crypto, the markets where the dip-buy fails. Win rates are low (35-45%); the money comes from a few big winners.
The wins are small and the rare losses are big. Most of these rules trade without a stop; the worst single TQQQ trade in our tests lost 48%. High win rate is not low risk.
Several versions make less than buy-and-hold. Turn-of-the-month made 6.7% a year, below just holding the index — the edge is being in the market only a third of the time, not more money.
It worked for 30 years; nothing says it must keep working. If US indexes stop bouncing, every one of these 18 dip-buying strategies stops working on the same day. They are one bet, not eighteen.
This page is research, not financial advice. Every test behind it is in the full ledger, with exact rules in each channel's "how we tested" panel.
Have a strategy you want checked? Send it to us.
← Back to home