Is PineTree Trader’s strategy legit? We backtested it.
The claim: “First inside bar of New York: 79% win rate”
Main test: S&P 500 5-min (34 months, 1-min fills). Every test is in the table below.
What we found
- 67% wins on Nasdaq 5-min with 1-minute fills, about +1.5 pts a trade.
- 2nd half lost.
Full test notes, including earlier and shorter tests
- Nasdaq 589 trades, 67% wins (he cites 79%), +1.5 points a trade, but the second half lost.
- S&P 58% wins and below zero at double costs.
- Our first 5-minute pass looked much better - checking every fill on 1-minute bars removed most of it.
Every test we ran
| Strategy | Market | Trades | Win rate | After costs | Versions profitable | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| First inside bar of the NY session | S&P 500 5-min (34 months, 1-min fills) | 596 | 58% (claimed 79%) | +22.2R | 5/6 | Breakeven |
| First inside bar of the NY session | Nasdaq 100 5-min (34 months, 1-min fills) | 589 | 67% (claimed 79%) | +43.8R | 5/6 | Breakeven |
R = multiples of the risk taken on each trade (−1R = one full stop-loss). Results include trading costs.
How we tested it
We turned the rules into code, ran them on years of real prices with trading costs, then re-ran nearby versions of the rules so one lucky setting can’t pass.
The exact entry, stop-loss, exit and filters behind every number on this page.
1-minute Nasdaq 100 and S&P 500 prices, January 2024–November 2026 (34 months, Dukascopy CFD, a stand-in for NQ/ES futures) (regular session. Fills checked on 1-minute bars).
futures ~1 tick slippage + fees (0.75 pt Nasdaq, 0.40 pt S&P)
6 versions tested - the full list with settings is in the paid report.
See every version ▾Nearby versions: why one lucky setting can’t pass
For every test we also ran nearby versions of the same rules: different profit targets, stop-losses, time windows, entries or filters. A strategy only counts as real when most of its versions make money after costs, not just the one that was shown in the video.
■ 75%+ of versions profitable ■ 40–74% ■ under 40%
Other channels we tested
in a $10 reportGet the rules →
We test the rules, not the people. Backtest results only; not financial advice. Past results do not guarantee future results.