Best strategies · tested on real prices

Best swing trading strategy (2026): 378 tested on real prices

Every "best swing trading strategy" video promises a high win rate. We took 378 swing trading (holding for days) strategies from YouTube, coded the exact rules and ran them on years of real prices with spread, slippage and fees. Here is what held up, and what didn't.

378strategies tested
31held up (Proof)
117small edge
119lost money as taught

The ranking: what held up

#Channel · strategyMarketVerdictTradesReal win rateNearby versions profitable
1Adam Khoo
Swing pullback to 50 MA
S&P 500 (SPY, 1993-2026)Proof10247%36 of 36
2Marvin
RSI crosses
S&P 500 (SPY daily, 1993-2026)Proof53075%18 of 18
3Pursuit of Edge
Buy the open 2% under the close 2 days ago
TQQQ (3x Nasdaq) daily, 2010-2026Proof52160%36 of 36
4Marvin
RSI crosses
Nasdaq 100 (QQQ daily, 1999-2026)Proof42472%18 of 18
5Pursuit of Edge
Buy the open 2% under the close 2 days ago
Nasdaq 100 (QQQ daily, 1999-2026)Proof42354%36 of 36
6Shaun Overton
Double 7s
S&P 500 (SPY daily, 1993-2026)Proof41874% (claimed 60%)12 of 12
7Ali Casey | StatOasis
Double 7s
S&P 500 (SPY daily, 1993-2026)Proof41874% (claimed 75%)12 of 12
8Jonee de Leon
Close under EMA10
S&P 500 (SPY daily, 1993-2026)Proof30745%24 of 24
9Backtested Strategies
RSI
S&P 500 (SPY daily, 1993-2026)Proof26376% (claimed 74%)16 of 16
10Jonee de Leon
Close under EMA10
Nasdaq 100 (QQQ daily, 1999-2026)Proof24542%24 of 24
11Critical Trading
Williams %R
S&P 500 (SPY daily, 1993-2026)Proof23781%8 of 8
12Backtested Strategies
RSI
Nasdaq 100 (QQQ daily, 1999-2026)Proof21569% (claimed 74%)16 of 16

Ranked by verdict, then by how many nearby versions of the rules also made money (one lucky setting can't rank high). Tap a channel to see all its tests.

Most hyped: biggest gap between claim and reality

#Channel · strategyMarketVerdictTradesReal win rateNearby versions profitable
1Trading Strategy Testing
ADX
EURUSD daily (2005-2026)Hype5723% (claimed 92%)0 of 12
2BKTraders (Kathy Lien & Boris Schlossberg)
5/50 SMA cross
Bitcoin 4h (2021-26)Hype41921% (claimed 85%)0 of 8
3Trading Strategy Testing
ADX
12 FX pairs daily (2005-2026)Hype58730% (claimed 92%)0 of 12
4Graph Insight
First 4-hour New York candle = range
Bitcoin 5-min (2021-2026)Hype4,02035% (claimed 92%)0 of 6
5Graph Insight
First 4-hour New York candle = range
EURUSD 5-min (2021-2026)Hype2,71536% (claimed 92%)0 of 6
6Graph Insight
First 4-hour New York candle = range
Gold 5-min (2015-2026)Hype5,46336% (claimed 92%)0 of 6
Want the exact rules, or to test your own?
The exact entry, stop and exit rules of every strategy above are for members. Or send us any YouTube video or your own rules and get a full test: real win rate, prop firm check, safe risk size and a TradingView script.
Test a strategySee the exact rules (Pro)

Questions

What is the best swing trading strategy?

In our tests the strongest swing trading (holding for days) strategy was Swing pullback to 50 MA from Adam Khoo on S&P 500 (SPY, 1993-2026): it was rated Proof and 36 of 36 nearby versions of its rules also made money. The best strategy for you also depends on your market, timeframe and how much drawdown you can live with.

How many swing trading strategy videos actually work?

Of 378 swing trading (holding for days) strategies from YouTube that we tested on real prices with trading costs, 31 held up (Proof), 117 showed a small edge, and 119 lost money as taught (Hype).

How do you test them?

We code the exact rules from the video, run them on years of real 1-minute prices with spread, slippage and fees, and also test nearby versions of the rules so one lucky setting can't pass. Real win rates are often far below the claims.

More rankings

Gold trading strategy · Day trading strategy · Forex trading strategy · Bitcoin trading strategy · Breakout trading strategy · Mean reversion trading strategy · Trend trading strategy · Momentum trading strategy · Scalping strategy · ICT trading strategy · S&P 500 trading strategy · Nasdaq trading strategy

Research on past prices only. Not investment advice. Data updated 22 Nov 2026.

Sign inMy account